Noah Garber and his family lived on a farm near North Manchester, Indiana, at least through the 1870's and 1880's. I do not know whether he died there and the body was taken back to Montgomery Co., Ohio, for burial, or whether he had returned to Ohio before his death. There are several letters from him in "The Heeter Family Letters."
This family profiled on page 76 of The Garber Genealogical and Historical Record, Vol. III. Noah and Dora had four children (Ida, Charles, Emma, and Ada) which I am not entering at this time.