Her death certificate records Sarah Pelfrey, age 83 years 1 month 24 days, born 5 Dec 1834 in Morgan Co., Ky, died 29 Jan 1918 in Morgan Co., Ky, widowed, father Beverly McClain, mother’s maiden name Lydia Day, both born in Ky, cause of death senile pneumonia, informant Victor Pelfrey, Elamton, Ky, burial at her home place.

Morgan County marriage register A records marriage on 16 Aug 1855 of Edward H. Pelphrey and Sarah Caskey, at Beverly McClain’s by John Williams, witnesses Peter Day, Ambrose Williams, and Allen Day Jr.

1860 census of Rowan Co., Ky, lists as family #52:
Pelfrey, E. H., 27; Sarah, 25; S. A. Jones (female), 8; Lydia A., 3. All born in Kentucky. (I have not identified S. A. Jones.)

1870 census of Rowan Co., Ky, Christy Creek precinct, lists as family #33:
Pelfrey, Edward, 37, farmer; Sarah, 35; Lydia, 12; John, 9. All born in Ky.

1880 census of Morgan Co., Ky, Elk Fork precinct, enumerated 12 June, lists on p. 18 as family #129/130:
Pelfrey, Edward H., 46; Sarah, 45, wife; John W., 19, son; Henry C., 9, son; Armilda, 7, dau.

The next household is Beverly Pelfrey age 22 with wife Louisa.

In 1900 they were listed as Edward H. Pelfrey age 68, and Sarah age 65, with their son Henry.