1860 census of Pendleton Co., Ky, Boston Station, enumerated 16 June, lists on p. 46 as family #314:
Sennet Goodpaster, 25, farm worker; Margaret, 21; Amanda, 5; Abraham, 2; Catherine, 3/12. All born in Ky.

(There are two Sorrell families on the same page who may also be from Bath Co.)

1870 census of Preble Co., Ohio, Dixon township, Campbellstown P.O., enumerated 20 June, lists on p. 1 as family #2:
Goodpasture, James, 36, farm hand; Margaret, 33; Amanda, 14; Abraham, 12; Catherine, 10; John C., 8; George M. (male), 5; Paul, 3; Belle, 2; infant (female), 3/12, b. Indiana. All except the baby (who would be Alphoretta) born in Kentucky.

1880 census of Bath Co., Ky, Wyoming prec., enumerated 3 June, lists on p. 5 as family #40/41:
Goodpaster, Sennet, 47; Margaret, 44, wife; John C. B., 19, son; George A., 17, dau; Paul, 15, son; Alfreta, 10, dau; Henry, 8, son; Mary J., 6, dau; Ida M., 5, dau. All born Ky Ky Ky.

The next household is that of Harrison Riddle and Lydia [Boyd], whose son John Mason Riddle their daughter Aphoretta married in 1887.