Kitty had five known daughters and one son, William Jesse Sutphin. Of the five daughters, only two of them married: Catherine to William Anderson Bolt, and Lucretia to James Madison Spence. The other three daughters all had families of their own without benefit of spouse. Isabelle had four sons and two daughters, Rebecca had five daughters and one son, and Rachel had four daughters and one son. (Possibly more; these are the ones that show up in censuses.)

1830 census of Grayson Co., Virginia, lists:
Kitty Sutfin, 1 f 30-39; 1 f 20-29; 1 m 5-9; 2 f 5-9; 1 m < 5; 1 f < 5.