Bath Co., Ky birth records list twin girls Elizabeth W. and P.A. Goodpaster born 7 Mar 1854, father David Goodpaster, mother’s maiden name Martha Goodpaster.

The 1870 census lists twins Elizabeth and Susan Goodpaster, their age incorrectly reported as 13. Apparently they changed their minds about the name of the second twin. (The 1860 census cannot be found for this family.)