Bath Co. birth register lists the birth of Charles Goodpaster on 5 Oct 1856, father David Goodpaster, maiden name of mother Martha Goodpaster.

His death certificate records Charles Goodpaster, age 81, born 6 Aug 1856, died 6 May 1938 in Owingsville, Bath Co., Ky, single, father David Goodpaster, mother’s maiden name Martha Goodpaster, both born in Ky, cause of death organic heart disease, informant Mrs. Thomas Purvis, Owingsville, Ky, RR2, burial in Old Virginia cemetery.

There was also a Charles Webb Goodpaster born 14 Jan 1856 in Bath Co, son of Levi Goodpaster and Jane Allen; be careful not to get them confused.