1870 census of Rowan Co., Ky, (June 11), Christy Creek, p. 9, family 52:
John M. Caudill, 37, farmer; Fannie, 29; Samuel, 16; Henry, 15; Abel, 12; James, 3; Sarah, 1. All born in Ky.

1880 census of Rowan Co., Ky, Christy Creek precinct, lists as family #380:
John M. Caudill, 47, farmer; Fanny, 39, wife; James N., 13, son; Sarah, 11, dau; Rebecca, 9, dau; Jeff Davis, 8, son; Malinda, 5, dau; Tilden H., 3, son. All born in Ky.
(Households 379 through 384 are all Caudills.)

The birth register for their son Tilden gives her maiden name as Mary Penington.

Her death certificate records Fanny Caudill, age 88 years 5 months 5 days, born 12 Sep 1841 in Kentucky, died 18 Feb 1930 in Goshen township, Clermont Co., Ohio, widow of John Caudill, father Elijah Penington, mother’s maiden name Sarah Caudill, both born in Kentuckey, cause of death cerebral hemorrhage, informant Sarrah Walker, Goshen, Ohio, burial in Brown Co., Kentuckey.

Morgan Co. marriage books record marriage of J. M. Caudle and Fanny Pennington on 18 Jan 1866.